“It’s true that Barack Obama is on the move. I don’t know if it’s true President Bush called Musharraf and said, ‘Why can’t we catch this guy’”- Roger Ailes

This is the joke that got the Fox News-sponsored Nevada Democratic debate canceled. The joke that’s got Democrats nationwide up in arms, that Harry Reid finds indefensible, that has touched off a mass (and surprisingly high-level) rebellion against Fox News…

…and it’s actually a somewhat funny joke. Harmless, really. [Adam ducks as no-longer-fresh vegetables fly towards the lectern…]

Now here comes the obligatory don’t-get-me-wrong section: I’m not a fan of Fox News, as most of you know. I think Fox News has harmed journalism hugely and it’s good to see people standing up to it. Any news organization that explicitly refers to itself as a counterbalance to what it sees as biased coverage… well, they can’t possibly be objective themselves, by definition. Etc.! And what Fox News recently reported about Barack Obama and his early schooling was unbelievably sloppy and clearly motivated by this bias…

…but that Ailes joke was pretty funny. Not great, but definitely “Weekend Update”-worthy. It is, at its core, a Bush joke anyway.

Many of you are ready to blast me to atoms for this, I’m sure. I’m naive. I can’t see Ailes’ real agenda. I’m unaware of how carefully-crafted the joke was to resonate with the “madrassa” story. Ailes’ joke is no different than Ann Coulter’s - a slap on top of a slur on top of an agenda. It’s the pattern, not the particulars. I know. I’ve been reading such things on the internet for the past couple of days, from the Democratic leadership to the angry commenters over at The Daily Kos.

And I think they’re all wrong. It’s an easy, silly joke. “Obama” and “Osama” are only one letter off, and Bush is an easily-confused man. Zing! It’s a joke that I would have made. I don’t think I’d have been particularly proud of it, but I’d have made it. In fact, I have little doubt that I did, at one point, on a “Wait Wait Don’t Tell Me!” If I didn’t, one of my fellow panelists probably did.

My guess is that to those mythical “plain folks,” those eternally “undecided” voters, this outrage over the “Obama” joke looks idiotic. Because, in point of fact, it is. Few centrists hearing the joke would think it was a slam on Obama. It’s hard to conceive that any even semi-persuadable voter would hear the joke and be subconsciously swayed by its hidden valences with the madrassa story or the Fox News agenda. And would anyone object to the joke if it didn’t come from Ailes?

And that, some say, is the point. By heading a skewed and intellectually corrupt “news” organization, Ailes has forfeited his right to make such jokes, or so the argument goes. I’m all for watching those conservative “jokesters” carefully, and Ann Coulter’s poison is something we all ought to keep our eyes on. But this… come on. The amount of linguistic gymnastics that one has to do to make this particular joke not merely a “Bush is stupid” joke means that it is probably what Occam’s Schick would suggest: A “Bush is stupid” joke. As a comedy writer, I’ll break it down: The idea that “Osama” and “Obama” sound alike isn’t funny. Implying they ARE alike is a non-starter, laugh-wise. But saying that Bush might confuse two vastly different and hard-to-confuse individuals based on a superficial similarity between their names? Bingo!

Again, Ann Coulter’s joke, if one found it funny, could only be funny if you understood that Ann is “not allowed” to call someone a “faggot,” and that that’s precisely what she wanted to call John Edwards. That’s worth getting our collective panties in a bunch over. [Yes, I found the preceding sentence as disturbing to type as you did to read.]

All of this said, I still approve of the Democrats finally standing up to Fox News. They should’ve done it years and years ago, and if they had, Fox News would never have risen to the heights of popularity it currently enjoys. By pretending it was just another news channel and by bellying up to the giant, slimy trough labeled “Air Time,” the liberals and the rational moderates of this country gave Fox News its “Respectable News Channel” Halloween costume. Taking that costume back is not a bad idea at all. Behaving like cartoons ourselves is, though.