(AP) WASHINGTON - The White House on Sunday disagreed with Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid’s claim that the Iraq war was “the worst foreign policy mistake” in U.S. history.
One of the best things about being White House Press Secretary is my nearly unlimited access to the White House’s rich collection of letters, diaries, and historical documents. It gives me a perspective on history that people who haven’t worked here really can’t possibly have. Those volumes, there on the shelves, allow me to see into the world of Presidential history in a whole new way, and when the day comes that I finally get the chance to take those books down from the shelves and start reading them, well, I think it’s safe to say that I’ll know even more.
It’s what makes it so hard to talk to the press. They just don’t have the access and breadth of knowledge of past and present, and sometimes it’s hard to be patient when all I want to say is, “Trust me, if you had even a little bit of the knowledge that I could have at a moment’s notice, you’d see why your questions are so dumb.”
I don’t say that of course. But I’m always tempted.
So when I heard Harry Reid say that Iraq was the United States “worst foreign policy mistake…” well, I think ol’ Harry could use a quick dose of some of the realities that are very likely contained in those austere volumes that are literally within arms’ reach of my desk as I write this. You want mistakes, Reid? Here:
- In 1889, Benjamin Harrison mistook Bolivia for a club sandwich. Even Harrison himself wasn’t sure how this happened, or how he actually managed to butter the entire city of Santa Cruz in April of that year. He later attempted to make amends by establishing the first “Pan-American Congress,” but the damage had been done. Even today, Bolivians refer to awkward social situations as “Mantequillas de Harrison.”
- Everyone knows Calvin Coolidge as the man who presided over the risk-free economic boom of the late-20’s, but did you know that he also once declared war on the Galapagos Islands? It’s true, I think. An invasion force of 35,000 men quickly took the largest island from a few very confused iguanas.
- And how come nobody ever mentions FDR lending Hitler his record collection in 1936? Or Chester A. Arthur’s Indonesian “fart heard round the world?” Or “Zachary Taylor and the Chamber of Secrets?” Or the time Franklin Pierce had Madrid carpeted?
No, the fact is that none of these quite-possibly real events fit into the liberal media’s agenda, so you never hear about them. Which allows guys like Harry Reid to blab on about Iraq being the “worst” foreign policy mistake in history. As you’ve seen, it’s in seventh place at the very least, and that’s not even counting William Howard Taft’s Invasion on Albuquerque (”Well, it sounded foreign!”). Clearly, by these standards, the Iraq thing is… less bad.
—–
[With apologies to Chris, who does this, and does it better, on a daily basis.]





31 comments
cooper
February 19, 2007 at 1:28 pm
1Tony, I’ve got 2 words for you - Ron Nessen.
Murray
February 19, 2007 at 3:37 pm
2I don’t know about the worst presidential mistakes, but I can sure tell you about the worst electoral mistakes.
dee
February 19, 2007 at 3:40 pm
3“Harrison butter” — another useful phrase enters the lexicon.
gillian
February 19, 2007 at 4:08 pm
4O.T. You know it’s probably a good idea that Britney Spears is not spending quality time with her new baby right now. She seems to have some mighty demons raging inside her head - what’s left of it. The kid’s better off with the nanny for a while.
Maximum Bob
February 19, 2007 at 4:13 pm
5I’ve always thought that Bush’s invasion of Iraq was on a par with the time Martin Van Buren had New Jersey painted, in that things looked pretty good for the first month or so.
siobhan
February 19, 2007 at 6:17 pm
6Sorry, can’t find any source of humor in this one. In our home, we’ve been living with the trauma of seriously broken bones/body for three years now. It’s nothing compared to what some of these guys have been through (Bill had no amputation, paralysis or brain injury), but I can most assuredly relate to the issues of rehab and ongoing care that they face. It’s annoying to go through this when it’s your insurance company and the semi-broken medical system doing it to you. When it’s the government who put you in harm’s way in the first place who’s behind the mess, it’s inexcusable. No other word works.
I’m just fucking disgusted. The only good thing is that the story seems to be getting picked up widely. Those fucking bastards didn’t want to admit the cost of this war for three years. They tried to do it on the cheap with equipment, training and manpower, and now they’re doing it with medical care.
There is not a circle in hell hot enough for them. Fuck every single one of them. EVERY ONE.
Dale
February 19, 2007 at 6:58 pm
7And Pulitzers for Anne Hull and Dana Priest. This (Judith Miller, are you reading?) is what journalism is supposed to be and do.
Ann
February 19, 2007 at 7:38 pm
8Every a-hole with a “Support the Troops” yellow ribbon on his or her car should have to read this article. The legends of war protestors spitting on returning Vietnam soldiers are nothing compared to this.
SeattleDan
February 19, 2007 at 8:24 pm
9Jonah Goldberg puts those whiny veterans in their place:
http://www.salon.com/opinion/greenwald/index.html
hedera
February 19, 2007 at 8:36 pm
10Sorry, SeattleDan, not being a premium Salon subscriber, I can’t read the Jonah Goldberg article. I have, however, read enough of siobhan’s Washington Post article (I couldn’t stand to finish it) to agree with her 100%. I don’t actually believe in hell; but the need for an appropriate place to put the people who are responsible for this is the best justification I can think of for one.
I don’t have siobhan and Bill’s experience with insurance companies, I did have to spend about half of my rehab time after my last knee surgery, persuading my company’s disability insurance firm that yes, I did have a major medical procedure and yes, I was entitled to disability leave on salary. This was because the insurance firm was too lazy to figure out how to get my medical information out of Kaiser, even though I had signed a release. So I’ve been a few small steps down that road.
The really infuriating thing about the whole incident is the way the senior administration people trumpet “support the troops” and “we can’t let the troops down” - and then they do this. I wish I could say I was surprised, but I can’t. I’m not surprised. I’m merely appalled.
SeattleDan
February 19, 2007 at 8:50 pm
11Hedera, it’s actually a Glenn Greenwald article which quotes Goldberg extensively. I don’t subscribe to Salon either, but could read it. Maybe something else is going on. In essence Goldberg doesn’t trust Hull and Priest and suggests, and I’m not kidding, that Faux News sic Geraldo on this story. Then we’d get something closer to the truth.
Two magic words, friends: Socialized Medicine. Health care, especially for our Vets, is a right and not a frickin’ privelege.
David
February 19, 2007 at 9:06 pm
12“There is not a circle in hell hot enough for them. Fuck every single one of them. EVERY ONE.”
siobhan, you took the words right out of my mouth.
hedera
February 19, 2007 at 9:08 pm
13Sigh. The soldiers in the rotting buildings are lying about their surroundings, yes? And Geraldo - Geraldo?? - could ferret out the truth? Geraldo wouldn’t recognize the truth if it bit him on the ankle. For that matter, neither would Fox News. On the other hand, given the situation, the more people investigating and publishing what they find, the better.
And I have to disagree with you, Dan. Health care for our veterans is not a privilege, nor is it a right - it is a DUTY. For the rest of us.
SeattleDan
February 19, 2007 at 9:24 pm
14Amen, hedera. Point taken.
cooper
February 20, 2007 at 4:16 am
15Dana Priest did a story about this last night on Countdown. Building 18 is an old hotel, with the emphasis on old. You’ll be happy to know, however, that the Army has been working on this for several months and now the mouse infestation in the building is down to “manageable” levels. No mention of the cockroach body count.
David
February 20, 2007 at 8:08 am
16I think they should relocate all of the wounded troops who’ve been put in these abominable facilities to the homes of high-ranking members of the executive branch and every congressperson who voted for this war. Set up the necessary care equipment, mandate a pool of all doctors and other health care people who voted for Bush/Cheney ‘04 to provide the medical care these troops we support need (the logistics can be worked out - there doesn’t seem to be any problem mandating that these troops go get blown up). I feel certain these health care professionals would jump at the chance to show how much they care (actually, some of them do, of course). Everyone at Fox News should be assigned to eight-hour shifts with the most seriously wounded immediately before they go on air. Geraldo and that twit at the LA Times could be in charge of overseeing the transfers, specifically working from inside these places.
I also think a cross with the name of each troop killed by the Yellow Rose’s War of Aggression should be placed on the White House lawn and a banner bearing each name hung on the front of the vice-president’s residence.
Recommended reading regarding the military’s new recruitment standards plus a brilliant suggestion by a congressman from New York to Condi Rice regarding the best use of the language experts being run out of the military because they are gay:
http://thewashingtonnote.com/
piglet
February 20, 2007 at 12:51 pm
17Holy crap, Siobhan. That article is infuriating. Thanks for the link.
Murray
February 20, 2007 at 4:08 pm
18A soldiers song.
“I’d storm into Havana just to steal Castro’s beard,
I’d blow into Baghdad to kick Sadam’s Butt,
I guess I just don’t know the meaning of fear,
But, please, please, please please, please,
Don’t make me,
Shower with a Fairy,
A Fairy is so scary.” -Fred Small
Just Jay
February 20, 2007 at 4:41 pm
19Murray (#18)
Is that Fred Small from Bangor Maine? My sister used to be a big fan and a close friend. Every time I visited she would drag me off to any place he was playing.
Jay
cooper
February 20, 2007 at 6:51 pm
20This is gillian’s turf, I know, but I thought with the Libby trial wrapping up, you may want to see this. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/opinions/cartoonsandvideos/toles_ main.html?name=Toles&date=02162007
Boomer
February 20, 2007 at 6:59 pm
21Well I’ll be damned. The Brits have won their part of the War on Iraq, declared victory and are getting the hell out. Tony Blair must be smarter than he looks. I think it helps if you just quit spending so much time curled up on W’s lap.
http://www.cnn.com/2007/WORLD/meast/02/20/uk.iraq.troops/index.html
gillian
February 20, 2007 at 7:59 pm
22That’s okay, cooper. I saw it yesterday, but didn’t have time to send it in. By the way is it just me, or does June Morgan seem younger, hotter and sassier than she used to be? They must have a new artist. Of course, Rex is still the consummate schmuck. Whatever, June certainly does it for me.
http://www.dailyink.com/en-us/content_offerings/features.php
David
February 20, 2007 at 9:21 pm
23Wicked cartoon (with the emphasis on wicked re the outing of Valerie Plame), cooper. Here’s hoping public contempt for what Cheney has done erupts into palpable anger. Makes one long for tarring and feathering.
David
February 20, 2007 at 9:24 pm
24gillian, gotta second your comment about June.
Dale
February 20, 2007 at 10:01 pm
25Wow, David and Gillian! That’s 2 for 2 you agree on. You guys are perfect for each other…except somehow not.
tess
February 21, 2007 at 1:48 am
26*twitch* Too . . . many . .. things . . . to be . .. angry . . . about . ..
I just feel like a lot of this shit is because of apathy: I saw it all the time as a TA, I see it all the time on Food Network, I see it every time I get passed over in being hired as a store clerk or a barista when I see they’ve hired some “pretty, young thing” who can barely string a sentence togther gossiping with a co-worker while handing a customer change, and it’s become the US’s biggest export. It’s this sense that the people put in charge have NO sense of shame in what they’re doing half-assed, and that now they’re in charge, they’ve set up the system so that they don’t have to take responsibility for their fuck-ups. Who the fuck are they hiring as nurses and hospital admins? Are they the same nitwits I see passing off burnt coffee as eXpresso? Have we fallen so far as a country that everyone who’s in charge now are the same people in high school who barely scraped by a “C” in all their classes because they couldn’t be bothered to read the textbook because it was “boring”? I’m depressed, I’m bitter, and I’m mad as hell that I’m seeing this sort of shit happening all the time, because aparently like hires like, and who the fuck’s in charge? Some dickweed who can’t be bothered to pronounce “nuclear” correctly, and his semi-literate cadre of fratboy cronies who probably dress as lawn jockeys and Aunt Jemima for Black History Month.
The worst part is that I’m supposed to finish my thesis so I can get the hell out and find a job where I’m supposed to think, but I get so depressed that I feel like I have to rail against the world instead of doing what I need to do for myself. I’ve ruminated myself into a corner over shit like this, and I can’t even feel like I can do anything anymore.
gillian
February 21, 2007 at 4:36 am
27tess, look, you’ve gotten far in life, so far toward that very ambitous goal you’ve set for yourself. Next time you’re in a crowd, stop to look at the people around you. Unless you’re standing on the campus of a prestigious university, what percentage of the people that you see have accomplished anywhere near what you’ve achieved - pretty close of zero, I’d say. Come up for some air and then dive back down and get it finished. You can do it.
David
February 21, 2007 at 5:44 am
28tess, I’m pretty much toward the other end of the journey, and I still find myself sharing the same anger and frustration, but once again I have to second gillian.
Dale, the only problem I could imagine would be if gillian and I were actually vying for the same girl, who happened to be bisexual. Then I guess we would be the other featured showdown at the Grouseland Games.
Murray
February 21, 2007 at 10:11 am
29Just Jay,
Yes, that Fred Small. I met him back in Ann Arbor during the mid 70s.
Tess, if you really want to see zero brains, try teaching 6th grade math. (I’m between classes at the moment).
siobhan
February 21, 2007 at 10:39 am
30After being so angry, I needed something to laugh at. This did the trick.
tess
February 21, 2007 at 5:55 pm
31gillian and David,
Thanks for the encouragement. I feel better now that I’ve had a little rant. Except for the money issues. And the halfwits who’re earning the rent money I need to finish my thesis.
Murray,
Trust me, when you have high school students who’re asking you to find the answers for them in a 5-page passage from a history textbook and it’s just a factoid, you begin to wonder and start looking for the booze.