Without putting too fine a point on it, today the United States will enact a law that some say makes us stronger in our struggle against terror and others say condones torture and still others say makes it okay to molest circus clowns.

I think we can all agree that the third group in question is way off base. Frankly, I don’t know how they got into the discussion. But as for the other two opinions… let’s try something novel: Read the legislation. Right here.

To me, reading this was a welcome antidote to the glossy party-line opinions of our politicians. I learned things. For one thing, I learned that I hate reading legislation. That’s okay. Legislation is written that way on purpose.

So what else did I learn? It’s tempting to say that this Act is a field guide to what the enemy can now feel free to do to our men and women. And in a way, it is (though I doubt any enemy OR friend has the patience to plow through this when wondering whether it’s okay to remove one’s prisoner’s fingernails without the aide of a professional manicurist (as far as I can tell, the answer to that one is still “no.”)). But it’s too complicated, and it seems to say that things that might have been okay before 2005 might not be okay today, though using information obtained through that no-longer-okay means if you obtained it before it became not-okay… is okay.

That’s no help to any aspiring torturer from any country around the world. I realize that. My apologies.

But then again, that’s just a rough reading from a layman. You might have more luck. Have at it. Without your sober conclusions, I’m afraid that Mr. Binkles, currently residing in my basement, is in for a very hard time.