[W]hy shouldn’t we think that the Iraq war has increased terrorism in the world, or at least the risk of it? The hornet’s nest analogy is apt, albeit clichéd. We were stung — and stung badly — well before the Iraq war. And after the multiple stings of 9/11 we decided to take the fight to nests. If my backyard is festooned with hornet nests, I will likely be safer from a sting on any given day if I do nothing than I will be on the day or days I begin destroying them. Since when is any large, important, task required to show positive results at every stage? — Jonah Goldberg
The doorbell rang, and for a moment, I was worried that Vice President Cheney had returned. My relief was short-lived, though: it was Donald Rumsfeld.
“I’ve just about repaired the damage to the back yard,” I said. “We braced the supports for the house, and replaced the soil. And we never found a single snake.”
“Do I care about snakes? Oh, my goodness, no,” said the Secretary of Defense, managing to smile despite his lack of lips. “Now, am I concerned about the hornets in your yard? Heavens to Betsy, yes indeed.”
“Hornets.” I said, dumbly.
“Hornets,” he said, and turned and gave a signal.
A troop of gardeners went into the backyard, each holding a rake. One of them approached a small hornet’s nest hanging from a live oak. I’d never noticed it before.
“Some people doubt the existence of hornets,” said Rumsfeld, with a look of triumph. “And we can’t afford that kind of defeatism in the face of such an enemy.”
“Okay, that’s a hornet’s nest,” I said. “No question. But, Secretary Rumsfeld, they’ve never bothered — ”
One of the gardeners, with Rumsfeld urging him on, whacked the hornets nest with a rake. Unsurprisingly, a swarm of insects emerged from the nest and began attacking the gardeners, who writhed and screamed in pain.
“Goodness,” said the Secretary of Defense. “Lawn care can be untidy sometimes.”
He urged the workers on, and grimly, they each began whacking the nest in turn. Many of them fainted from the pain, lying still on the ground. Or at least, I hope they had fainted. The SecDef and I ran inside and slammed the door shut, as thousands of hornets banged against the glass windows.
“Where are they all coming from?” I said.
“They don’t like it when we stir them up,” said Rumsfeld. “Of course they don’t. That’s why it’s so important to do it.”
My yard was flooded with stinging insects. It’s as if they were coming from all over the neighborhood, out of some sense of entomological solidarity.
“There’s one thing I don’t understand,” I said. “Why the hell can’t you do this to Jonah Goldberg? It’s his damned metaphor.”
Rumsfeld polished his rimless glasses and smiled. “Jonah lives in a Manhattan apartment,” he said. “But I’m sure that if he had a backyard, he’d kick its ass.”





53 comments
Veronica
September 29, 2006 at 3:52 pm
1“Lots of things go badly until they go well”? That’s the most pathetic excuse for screwing up that I’ve ever heard. I’m going to try it on my boss next time he questions the quality of my work.
David
September 29, 2006 at 7:41 pm
2Jonah strikes me more and more as possessed of a pathetic intellect. Does he really think through what he is saying, or is he driven only by the need to say something, however absurd it might be? At least he did provide the stimulus for another very entertaining riff by Her Shadowiness,
SpottedDog
September 29, 2006 at 11:35 pm
3I think if he had said there was a light at the end of the tunnel I would have been convinced. If he had mentioned that the cloud had a silver lining I would have praised his clear thinking, but the hornets nest analogy is a bit too complicated.
cooper
September 30, 2006 at 12:40 am
4David, re Jonah Goldberg - no, yes, very.
David
September 30, 2006 at 6:28 am
5cooper,
As my Cajun friend’s father used to say, “Yeah, you right.” I do see a certain pathos, however, in such misdirected intellect.
Sienna,
Make that Her Superb Shadowness (there’s a dj in Orlando who goes only by Shadow).
Sharon
September 30, 2006 at 6:32 am
6As someone who is deathly allergic to hornets and wasps, and who grew up in Texas where they are even more prevalent and more aggresive than they are here in the Northeast, I think the analogy is a good one. It’s the conclusion that is bogus. And it certainly doesn’t justify the means that this administration has used; if anything it refutes them.
But then the Current Occupant is not concerned with subtlety, nuance, or good old police work as demonstrated by UK authorities. Nosiree, that’s not dramatic enough. He’s gotta show everyone who’s boss, in the Code of the West manner that only a blue-blooded Yalie can know so well.
Mojo
September 30, 2006 at 8:54 am
7But I thought the current story is that we went into the back yard to free the hornets from the tyranny of their nest. Then they’d turn into butterflies and give us all lots of flowers and nectar. Doesn’t that sound like a good plan?
Demento
September 30, 2006 at 9:37 am
8If one has been stung, one destroys the nest before one is stung again. Of course one does not send in a fully armored knight to knock down the nest with a lance. The small hornets will go through the armor’s chinks and kill the knight. One does not send in an unprotected rube with a rake. One sends trained experts properly equipped. And, most importantly, one sends the experts to the location of the nests, not to the holes of potentially harmful scorpions who have done nothing more than irritate you by your knowledge of their existance. One also knows that new nests will be built. Hornets can’t take over the back yard but one needs to get rid of the nests if one wants to enjoy the back yard.
piglet
September 30, 2006 at 10:29 am
9Yeah, what Demento said, except that now the hornets are coming to the defense of the scorpions. Huh. Never saw that coming…
David
September 30, 2006 at 10:54 am
10You guys are clearly buying into the Hornets Who Hate Our Freedom propaganda, and are also probably cut-and-run tree huggers to boot.
Warthogs and Abrams tanks exist to take out hornet nests, along with the trees, at least when they are hanging over vast pools of black gold.
David
September 30, 2006 at 10:57 am
11Excellent WW,DTM today, even though no Adam. Tom is starting to get the hang of it.
cooper,
Do Charlottites really rag on Gastonia like that? Got a strong signal for WW, DTM in Hendersonville from the Charlotte station.
SeattleTammy
September 30, 2006 at 11:09 am
12It was a good show - up until I had to start screaming at idiot Jody, who knew nothing about the Detainee Bill. and still, she WON!
Freeway Blogger is a group who puts up big signs along freeways. My recent favorite of theirs was “Turning into a Torture State … without so much as a whimper”.
It’s worse than that. There is no whimper at all. The Jodys of America can just giggle their way through anything.
Thompson
September 30, 2006 at 12:25 pm
13Waging what’s supposedly an offensive war in a way that, from all currently available view points, appears to consist of an endless series of defensive reactions isn’t failure.
It’s “deferred success.”
*ducks before someone can punch him for the reference*
Sharon
September 30, 2006 at 12:26 pm
14This summer the wasps once again took up residence in my porch lights. I took a couple of plastic bags that the newspapers come in, and one night, after they were all asleep in the nests, I covered the porch lights with the bags and tied them shut. The wasps died a horrible death by starvation and/or asphixiation, and I’m sure I’ve accumulated some bad karma because of it, but under the same circumstances I’d do the same thing again.
Sure, a lot of people wanted me to take a stick and knock down the nests in broad daylight, like a real man, but I knew I was smarter than they were.
jack*
September 30, 2006 at 12:59 pm
15Analogies are stupid generally, but this littany of articles comparing international relations to yard care is getting absurd. For the “terrorists are garden pests” analogy to work at all you’d have to find the best way to turn helpful insects deadly and then employ that very technique as the means to try to eradicate them.
On WWDTM, I was sort of hoping Kevin Clash would lose so he’d offer to let Elmo record an answering machine message.
Pope Benny, 16
September 30, 2006 at 2:57 pm
16Sharon, as a gardener, we say a weed is any plant in the wrong place. Ditto with wasps. A girl has to be able to enjoy her porch. I love nature, but I have no problem taking out hornet based insurgencies. As for bad karma, do 100 “Hail Mary’s”, go and sin no more.
Sharon
September 30, 2006 at 4:54 pm
17jack*, I think we all get at least one shot at it (the analogy, that is).
Thanks, Pope!
Dale
September 30, 2006 at 9:38 pm
18I think Goldberg’s continued use of animal analogy/metaphor’s is actually quite telling. The administration views everyone who is not a white-American-flag-waving born-again-supporter of this administration… as an animal, particularly one on the lower rungs of the evolutionary totempole. Identical, irrational, instinctive, genetically programmed to do whatever it says they do in the encylopedia. Their actions are not shaped by history, they neither have nor respond to dialogue, logic, negotiation, compromise. A hornet stings you because it is a hornet and that is what hornets do and will always do.
People, social groups, nations etc., however, act for reasons, and respond to reasons, and you can affect the way they act and the way their children act. There are I know, people out there who “want to cut my head off” and probably could not be talked out of it. But I am convinced that these are exceptions within their own society, and that such exceptions exist in every human society. There are violent psychopaths, but that does not make their group deterministically violent or psychopathic. Scholars, academics, concerned citizens can and do all have lots of different ideas about just what Iraqis, or Muslims, or any “Other” thinks and perceives and wants, but the administration doesn’t even seem to realize that Iraqis, Muslims, Others ARE thinking, percieving, wanting, organisms and not…bugs.
Maybe someone should start a blog using cuter animal metaphors. If we’re going to treat the rest of the world like beasts, we would be probably have better results thinking in terms of puppies and kittens.
Michel Plamondon
October 1, 2006 at 11:20 am
19But then, if you know anything about hornets, you will wait for a cold rainy day to get rid of them. They’ll all be home and unresponsive from the cold.
Just Jay
October 1, 2006 at 11:43 am
20This is way off topic, but I want to congratulate SeattleDan and SeattleTammy on the fine profile of their store that was published this weekend in the Seattle Times Sunday magazine. Here’s hoping that you get discovered by Northwest book lovers and your business takes off. Just don’t forget all the little people who knew you when….
Jay
Peter Sagal
October 1, 2006 at 1:25 pm
21And while we’re on the subject of congratulations, let’s also tip the hat to the proprietor of this site, Mr. Felber, on the very good review of “SB” in the Sunday New York Times Book Review. Here: http://www.nytimes.com/2006/10/01/books/review/Curtis.t.html
SeattleDan
October 1, 2006 at 2:19 pm
22Thanks, Just Jay! And congrats, again, Adam, on the review.
Link to the story on our store at: http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/pacificnw10012006/
David
October 1, 2006 at 2:20 pm
23Love the L’il Abner look of Evil Eye Felber.
The challenge for Tour de Farce #2 has been issued. Don’t wanna hear any “I’m really, really tired” nonsense, even if it’s true. Am assuming #2 is already taking shape in Adam’s delightfully foetid mind (well, foetid or not foetid, depending on whether or not his mind has been observed).
cooper
October 1, 2006 at 4:49 pm
24Dale, I agree with your comment above, but there is one small error I must point out. “The administration views everyone who is not a white-American-flag-waving born-again-supporter of this administration… as an animal, particularly one on the lower rungs of the evolutionary totempole.”
As we know, this administration does not believe in evolution, so we who disagree would be dirty, cloven hoofed, gutter animals. It’s a small point, I know, but we don’t want to give them credit for intelligence that’s not there.
siobhan
October 1, 2006 at 5:21 pm
25Cooper, always a stickler for details. Good point.
The one part of the story that doesn’t add up for me is that I thought this administration wanted to have bugs everywhere?
cooper
October 1, 2006 at 5:51 pm
26David, re Gastonia: yes it is the butt of many, many jokes and, though I grew up 10 miles away and my brother and his family still live there, I must say that the town is deserving of every snicker.
There is a town in east Tennessee (Erwin) where, back 100 years ago, a circus elephant was startled by some loud noise coming from the crowd, while it was performing its act, that caused it to stampede and accidently step on a small child, killing it. The citizens of Erwin organized a posse, found the elephant (not far from the Big Top and contently eating grass), threw a rope around its neck and lynched it in the town square. I told you that story of ancient jurisprudence to tell you this - the citizens of Gastonia would no doubt mete out the same sort of justice today and be damned proud of it. Gastonia - a town singularly trap in a time bubble of Bible Belt stupidity. (For the record, it’s Charlotteans)
cooper
October 1, 2006 at 6:20 pm
27Adam, the FanAp Shop is missing out on a real money maker - the Deborah Johnstone profile mud flaps. It would be HUGE down here - especially in the Greasy Corners section of Gastonia, where every one drives a truck (or a 4-on-the-floor red Camaro with dual exhaust and twin 4 barrel carburetors).
SpottedDog
October 1, 2006 at 6:41 pm
28Cooper, Tragic story. I am wondering. Do you know how the townspeople went about lynching the elephant? I suppose it was shot, but when I think of lynching hanging comes to mind. Dictionary.com indicates that lynching doesn’t necessarily imply hanging though.
Harold
October 1, 2006 at 7:08 pm
29Off topic, but if you missed Spike Feresten last night, you missed a whole LOTTA Adam. Baby got back…fat.
And now I understand an exchange I had with Adam at the Felberpalooza.Murray was taking pictures of Adam as he modelled the official Felberpalooza T-shirt. To let Murray get pictures of the back, Adam peeled off his topshirt partway and held it around his waist while flexing his back and looking coy. After Murray got his pictures, I said in a seductive yet sinister purr, “Now, lose the shirt.” Adam looked at me and said, “You wouldn’t believe how often I’ve been hearing that lately.” (Or words to that effect.) Now that I’ve seen Adam half-naked on national television, I understand.
Harold
October 1, 2006 at 7:26 pm
30SeattleDan, I didn’t see a link to your website in that article! The bastards!
By the way, the word “Stitch” is still spelled wrong on your site…the word “better” ends abuptly in the phrase “Could things get any bette”…and I can’t find the photos from Adam’s signing!
cooper
October 1, 2006 at 7:27 pm
31SpottedDog, right you are, but in this case no shots, it was hanging - from a very large and strong oak tree and perhaps using the train it came into town on, to pull on the rope in order to lift it off the ground and hang by its neck until death. This is, of course, the traditional way southerners lynch their victims and these citizens were traditionalists.
siobhan, now it’s you with the good point!
cooper
October 1, 2006 at 7:51 pm
32Sienna, what has the neighborhood association made of all these unapproved changes? This could cost you a freakin’ fortune!
SeattleTammy
October 1, 2006 at 8:00 pm
33Cooper- your story gave me a flashback- Vince Kohler in his debut novel, Rainy North Woods (St. Martins 1990) had a circus come to town and when the elephant stomps a Vietnamese (that figures in later, not breaking Chesterton’s ten laws) who was feeding him, the Circus owner becomes enraged and hangs the elephant. It was brutal and shocking, Vince always put in whacky yet quite violent murders in his books.
The owner got the elephant over to a railway siding and used a huge wrecker with a crane that was used for removing broken rail cars. No one from the circus took him seriously until he bolted himself in the cabin and did winch up the chain.
Vince was an old news paperman from Portland OR. He had probably read of your elephant story.
ps Luckily, Booksellers alphabetize their front rooms and can find the book in question quickly!
cooper
October 2, 2006 at 12:55 am
34SeattleTammy, here I was marvelling at your total recall of obscure incidents and you go & drop in your “ps”. Yes I agree, the two stories do sound remarkably similar. Congrats on the story in the Seattle Times. As a small business owner myself, I hope that gives your business a good boost.
David
October 2, 2006 at 7:39 am
35cooper,
Living about 20 miles from Ocoee, famous in Florida folklore for the great lynching of 1925, and remembering what the function of Florida sheriffs and justices-of-the-peace was when I was a wee tad in Central Florida, I have no trouble imagining either Gastonia (I’ve driven through but never spent any time in that cultural hub of the occident) or Erwin. Circus elephants, n—-s, they were animals with specific functions circumscribed by the ever present possibility of a good lynching (we did love our family outings).
I can imagine George Allen, Jr. (and I assume Sr.) saying, “Bring up the shines.”
Ann
October 2, 2006 at 10:25 am
36Yes, Harold, Adam is leading the “back fat is sexy again!” movement. I can’t wait to see what the fashion mags make of it. I’m thinking “People’s Sexiest Man” for 2007.
Rick
October 2, 2006 at 6:11 pm
37Harold, can you share the picture of Adam in the Felberpalooza shirt? I didn’t get to see the final product.
Harold
October 2, 2006 at 8:30 pm
38Murray, the picture was one that you took and distributed. Do I have permission to reproduce it on my blog? (And can I post the ones of us on the bikes, right before my Tragic Biking Accident?)
ice weasel
October 2, 2006 at 10:50 pm
39You know, I was all set to call cooper on being terribly full of shit and then, I found this…(from Amazon)
There is no doubt that in 1916 a five-ton circus elephant was lynched from a 100-ton Clinchfield railroad crane car in the little town of Erwin, Tennessee. The details of the execution and the tragic events leading up to it, however, are clouded in nearly a century of oral tradition. From one retelling to the next, facts are distorted and embellished; legend, instead of truth, is often accepted as fact. This book is an attempt to bring together all the known facts about the hanging and to till in with educated guesses the missing parts of the puzzle.
The bizarre story of the hanging of Mary the elephant begins in St. Paul, Virginia, where Sparks World Famous Shows stopped for a one-day stand. The story ends in Erwin, three days later. Between these little towns ran the shiny twin rails of the Carolina, Clinchfield and Ohio Railroad (popularly known as “The Ciinchfield”). The Clinchfield is an indispensable prop in the story of Mary and those people whose lives she touched.
Wow coop, I thought I could never be surprised again.
ice weasel
October 3, 2006 at 6:09 am
40Is someone moderating and deleting comments now?
Siobhan
October 3, 2006 at 10:46 am
41Free Weasel’s comment!
Free Weasel’s comment!
Free Weasel’s comment!
Hey Hey! Ho Ho! Weasel’s comment had got to show!
What do we want? Weasel’s comment!
When do we want it? NOW!!
(see, I learned a lot at the marches.)
Siobhan
October 3, 2006 at 10:47 am
42(oops - “has” got to show.)
Sharon
October 3, 2006 at 11:21 am
43Condi Rice’s latest “the dog ate my homework excuse” for not responding aggressively to the pre-9/11 terrorist threats reminds me of a routine that Steve Martin did in his stand-up days:
Whenever you’re arrested for armed robbery, just say, “I FORGOT armed robbery was illegal.”
Sharon
October 3, 2006 at 11:22 am
44(I meant to cite http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/ap/world/4232571.html fpr that last quote, but it didn’t come out like I expected.)
dee
October 3, 2006 at 12:10 pm
45Everybody sing!
Go down, Jennifer,
Way down in Cyber-Land
Tell Ol’ Fanny
Let my comment go!!
Dale
October 3, 2006 at 4:38 pm
46Maybe Fanny is hungry from not enough spam? Here, Fanny Fanny Fanny, here Fanny Fanny Fanny…
viagra herbal stock tip Nigerian bank global domination money earn weight DVDs discount get rich quick vitamin sex God legal discount
That should keep her happy for a while
David
October 4, 2006 at 6:10 am
47Dale,
So how do I go about investing in this exciting God/sex stock?
Dale
October 4, 2006 at 1:03 pm
48So glad you asked, David! It’s quite simple, really, just send me a check for $10K and I’ll handle it from there.
Off-topic: I’ll be at the Yankees-Tigers game tonight (the $10K will help cover this indulgence, and the health care costs associated with my pummeling from Yankees bleacher creatures). Go Tigers!
David
October 5, 2006 at 6:51 pm
49Great night for the Tigers! Siobhan must be doing some serious celebrating.
Is this comeback win a sign my stock investment will pay off handsomely? I’ll have to send a two-party, post-dated, out-of-state counter check. Will that be ok?
Dale
October 5, 2006 at 7:19 pm
50Post-dated, out-of-state, and counter are all fine (although I don’t know what that last one means), but sorry, this partisan has given up on two-party efforts.
cooper
October 5, 2006 at 7:56 pm
51Dale, a counter check is old school technology. In the old days, after opening a checking account and before your personal checks arrived, you could get a “counter” check (you had to go up to the counter and ask a teller to give you one). This was essentially a check where you would write in your new account number, write in you address, and present it as a normal check for payment of services, merchandise, etc. Assholes of the world soon realized they could get these counter checks, write in any account number that came to mind, and rip off merchants at will. Soon savvy businessman refused to accept counter checks and banks quit making them available. Ergo, counter checks are not a reliable means of doing business. Don’t take any wooden nickels, either. Here’s a picture of a counter check.
http://www.brightok.net/~bridges/fnb62co.jpg
Siobhan
October 5, 2006 at 10:06 pm
52David, I think Dee and Dale are even more D-lighted about D-troit. I am happy indeed, but must confess that I hadn’t realized that they were playing real baseball there again this season until Dee alerted us mid-summer. I’d lost interest in all baseball after the strikes, and paid only cursory attention for the past few years. The Tigers’ resurrection has been a very pleasant distraction this year. (And if they did end up playing a few games against the A’s, I’d probably try to weasel my way into a game.)
David
October 6, 2006 at 9:25 pm
53First, apologies to Dee for leaving her out of the Tigers celebration.
cooper,
Our counter checks at the grocery store at which I worked in the late fifties were even earlier tech. The customer filled in everything, including the name of the bank. We let only the customers we knew use them, and nary a one bounced. Some regular checks did, of course, but we did away with the counter checks just to be on the “safe” side. My favorite memory from that quaint time was the significant number of our black customers who kept a running tab during the week and ALWAYS paid on Friday evening or Saturday morning. The mutual trust between these customers and the Spelzhausens, who owned the independent grocery store and filling station, is one of my few fond memories of that era, which was filled with way, way, way too much in the way of unconscionable racial relations.