“It is unfortunate that we are in civil war… If this is not civil war, then God knows what civil war is.”
- Former Prime Minister Ayad Allawi

“What we’ve seen is a serious effort by them to foment civil war but I don’t think they’ve been successful.”
- Vice President Dick Cheney

“I think we have had a low-grade civil war going on in Iraq, certainly the last six months, maybe the last year.”
- Senator Chuck Hagel (R., Neb.)

“There has been an increase in sectarian violence but it is not a civil war.”
- British Defense Secretary John Reid

————————

“Domestic Fracas?”

“Intranational Spat?”

“Homeland Interfactional Armed Struggle Taking Place Under a Still Inadequately Manned but Undeniably Existent Fledgling Government that is at Least for the Moment Holding Firm in the Face of Sectarian Adversity?”

I guess those’d work. But they don’t have a beat you can dance to.

Your first question (don’t deny it!) has got to be, “Does it really matter whether we call it a ‘civil war’ or not?”

Of course it does.

I mean, it doesn’t matter to the people of Iraq, who are trying to get their lives together while dodging terrorist bombings and fomenting “revenge” violence against rival sects. Their lives will be the same tomorrow morning whatever we call the current situation. And naturally, it doesn’t matter to our 130,000+ American servicemen. Whether you call it a “civil war” or “youthful exuberance,” they’re going to be executing their missions while keeping a wary eye out for IEDs exploding candygrams for the foreseeable future.

But it matters to Guys In Suits like Allawi and Cheney, who will get much better or worse service in restaurants and hotels depending on what the answer is. But it also matters to all of us back home, particularly those of us who work in Hollywood or view its products. Remember: We are going to have to make a movie about this someday. And we have to know how the third act is going to play out.

Will it be a triumphant Sarge stomping down the Last Throes with his engaging and stalwart band of brothers, giving his boys a reluctant but hard-earned thumbs-up and a gruff smile around the stump of a well-chewed cigar as they all accept the cheers of the grateful throng? Or will it be a disillusioned young farm-boy looking back on the fiery ruin that has become a metaphor for his lost innocence as a helicopter lifts him away from Baghdad for the last time and uncomfortably thrashy rock music blares?

There’s no answer for that yet. Once we all agree that yes, it’s a civil war or no, it’s a speed bump on the road to triumph, we can all finish our treatments, polish our pitches, and get on with it, no matter what actually continues to happen on the ground over there.

You can help. You can help me, my Hollywood brothers and sisters, and your own cinematic and made-for-TV viewing experiences. Call your congressmen and senators, write to your local papers and demand some clarity on whether or not what’s happening in Iraq is or isn’t a “civil war.” It’s an easy call to make, and much more fun than demanding to know specifically what’s actually happening over there. And, as I said, it’ll really help us out over here, where the real fake war is going to be fought.