After two years, thousands of newspaper articles, hundreds of thousands of hours of television programming (about 40% of which was brought to you by MSNBC’s Dan Abrams), and one extremely disingenuous piece of legislation… Scott Peterson’s case is over. He’s going to be sentenced to death, and twenty to forty years from now he will be executed.
What a case! What drama! A guy kills his pregnant wife, there’s a ton of evidence against him, his alibis aren’t credible, and the jury finds him guilty. Who woulda seen that coming? No wonder the names of Scott, Laci, and Conner Peterson are so deeply ingrained in the national consciousness.
Quick - name one American soldier who has died in Iraq over the past two years. Just one.
Sorry, that was a bit of a trick question. Not important. Let’s carry on…
So much has changed thanks to the Peterson case. Back in April, for instance, President Bush signed “Laci and Conner’s Law.” This was an incredibly important piece of legislation - finally the epidemic of people killing pregnant women and their unborn babies and getting off with just a few weeks of community service will come to a halt. Those were dark times, but they’re behind us now.
Some nervous nellies on the left have called the law a trojan horse geared towards overturning Roe v. Wade. To shore up this ridiculous claim they’ve pointed to the fact that a lot of right-to-life activists who supported the bill were calling it “a trojan horse geared towards overturning Roe v. Wade.” To me, that’s pretty flimsy, circumstantial evidence. And just because US law now defines a “child in utero” as “a member of the species homo sapiens, at any stage of development, who is carried in the womb,” and allows someone to be prosecuted for the murder of such a child, how does that translate into abortion being outlawed? Puh-leeeze!
Dan Abrams, of MSNBC’s “The Abrams Report” ably explains his coverage of All Things Peterson nearly to the exclusion of all else on his blog (though he never spent much time on that rather boring new law - he stuck to the important stuff). “The outcome of the Peterson case will not impact international nuclear proliferation nor lead to peace in the Middle East. Anyone who tells you we are covering one of the more important stories of the day is a liar.” See? There’s no excuse! “It is… more newsmagazine than pure news.” So you’re sorry about filling a major news network with wall-to-wall Peterson during a war and the most important election of our lifetimes? Great. What’s that you say, Dan? “But there should be no shame.”
Oh. Abrams goes on to say that there’s a place at the “news dinner table” for “dessert” like the Peterson case. As long as you don’t serve only “sweets” like that brutal homicide.
Fair enough. Quick, Dan - off the top of your head name an American soldier who’s been killed in Iraq over the past two years. Heck, you’re a journalist, name a couple of ‘em.
I know, I know, it was another trick question. There have only been 1,297 American military fatalities in Iraq, and most of them, as far as most Americans can tell, didn’t have names. At least not like Laci, Conner and Scott have names. To remember someone’s name, after all, you have to see their face a few times, hear their story, and where would you find something like that about the men and women who are giving their lives for this country? If only there was some sort of institution or medium that was devoted to communicating the important events of the day, then we might know some names, but I guess it hasn’t been invented yet. We can dream, though.
Besides, our Administration believes that dwelling upon casualties is bad for the ol’ team spirit. Back in April, when the President signed The Unborn Victim’s of Violence Act with a flourish, he offered some names: “Laci, a beautiful young woman who was joyfully awaiting the arrival of a new son. They have also laid to rest that child, a boy named Conner, who was waiting to be born when his life, too, was taken.”
Quick, Mr. President, name a -
Oh, nevermind.





44 comments
Trackback from The Random Walk - Scott Peterson Gets the Death Penalty...
December 15, 2004 at 8:51 pm
Tom in Santa Clara
December 14, 2004 at 6:51 pm
1Agree wholeheartedly Adam! The news people out here in the Bay Area have been all over this story, including last evening’s news that had extensive interviews with jury members, the SF Chronicle had the interviews today and they are appearing on Larry King tonight. Its just outrageous that with 130,000 service members in Iraq, over 1,200 deaths and 10,000 battlefield injuries, over 5,000 deserters…and the news people are all over this (admittedly gruesome) murder and trial instead of addressing the real big issue out there. The local yokels only started talking with local reservists about the lack of armored vehicles after the question was posed to Rumsfeld
What’s that old newspaper saying…’If it bleeds it leads but if it thinks it stinks’? Well, there’s a lot of bleeding going on in Iraq and its not leading….wonder why?
Murray
December 14, 2004 at 7:15 pm
2If you think that legislators are awful, you should see their constituents.
If you think that news programs are awful, you should see their viewers.
How much time have I wasted listening to Scott Peterson news on NPR, or reading in the NY Time?
Not that much.
Back when there was only ABC, NBC and CBS they needed to be responsible in what they spent their time on. Now, with hundreds of outlets (owned by 8 corporations) people can dial in the amount of Peterson info they want.
Jimmy Breslin loaded his columns with the names and addresses of the fallen. At least one person cared.
Ann
December 14, 2004 at 7:55 pm
3Pat Tillman! He was famous because he was a football player who gave up a fortune AND he was an incredibly brave leader in battle. Until it turned out that he was killed by friendly fire. Best not mention him again.
tim
December 14, 2004 at 7:56 pm
4(Thick Austrian accent)
“Scott Peterson, you’re TERMINATED!”
Coming this Fall, only on FOX!
Ann
December 14, 2004 at 8:02 pm
5I just read the Abrams report and it made me wince–what bad writing! This is a gem:
“For some women, Scott Peterson represents the epitome of everything wrong with certain men…”
Yes, some women think that killing your pregnant wife is a strong negative. Other women, however…what? Don’t mind that much?
Karen
December 14, 2004 at 8:07 pm
6So, lemme get this straight…Candidate Felber, are you saying your *for* murdering pregnant women?
(Sorry about that, you just seemed a little hung up on the law.)
I do agree with the gist of your argument. If you think the coverage is bad in your fair city, try living in the Bay Area–on the Peninsula.
One of my biggest frustrations with the war is the myth that it doesn’t cost us anything. Our patriotic duty is to go shopping–spend those tax breaks. Given this mindset, is it any wonder the names of the fallen are quickly mentioned then forgotten?
Karen
December 14, 2004 at 8:08 pm
7I wish to add that I realize the word should be “you’re” not “your.” Momentary disconnect between brain and fingers.
adam
December 14, 2004 at 8:37 pm
8Ann -
Tillman died in Afghanistan.
[but his name occured to me as well…]
Ann
December 14, 2004 at 9:00 pm
9Ah, yes. Afghanistan–the good war. My mistake.
tess
December 14, 2004 at 9:20 pm
10Wow, I can’t name any soldier other than what’s-her-name who was captured and rescued on TV no less! What was her name again? Lyndie England or something? She was heroic AND lived! Or was she the one who helped brutalize prisoners in Abu Ghraib?
Oh well — must focus on Scott and Laci and their adorable fetus-corpse, Connor.
Rusty
December 14, 2004 at 10:04 pm
11I cannot tell you how glad I am that we don’t have TV. It always shocks most people when they hear that. I too am an NPR (and BBC) junkie. Still, I have to admit that I cannot name a single soldier who has fallen in Iraq. I’m going to fix that.
bjd
December 14, 2004 at 10:11 pm
12Butbutbut… NPR is *elitist*, you latte-drinking, Thai-Mexican fusion eating, hybrid car driving elitist.
Quick, someone call Homeland Security, there be *liberals* hanging around here.
God Bless Private Jessica Lynch!
:-P
craig
December 14, 2004 at 10:33 pm
13Adam
That is such a cold column. I bow humbly in the presence of your understated genius.
Was it Stallin who said “one death is a tragegy, a million is a statistic”? If it was, he probably said it in Russsian, though.
hedera
December 15, 2004 at 12:29 am
14Rusty - another non-TV watcher and NPR listener, I thought I was the only one! Welcome, brother! (Or sister, as the case may be)
Thank you, Adam, I was going to mention Tillman died in Afghanistan…
To do it justice, the S.F. Chronicle regularly publishes articles on California soldiers (can’t have EVERYTHING) who died in Iraq last week, with names, family photos, etc. I can’t remember the names either but it’s because it’s so painful.
wunderdog
December 15, 2004 at 12:34 am
15Adam, cable news is, uh, worthless. Save your money, keep the outrage.
Linkmeister
December 15, 2004 at 1:49 am
16There have been nearly a dozen soldiers from bases in Hawai’i killed in the past two weeks; our papers and TV stations have been covering those extensively. Peterson’s been a small sidebar to the articles/pictures of graveside services.
I never ever thought I’d be praising Hawai’i papers and television stations, but in this case they’ve been focused on what’s important to the residents.
Bob
December 15, 2004 at 3:44 am
17Dan Abrams may have a point about the value of all the trial coverage. I suspect that most Americans are as dismayed as I am over the debate that’s plagued us for the last 20 or 30 years, about whether it’s OK to kill your wife and unborn child. Thanks to the Peterson trial, the balance is being tipped ever so slightly in the direction of “No, it’s not.”
Now we can move on to trickier topics, such as whether you should entrust the running of the world’s greatest democracy to a guy who, had he been born to different parents, would be selling life insurance. And not the better kind of insurance, but one of those off-brands sold over AM radio to people with bad credit. Maybe Mr. Abrams, freed from the rigors of covering the trial, can give us a little help on this one.
Mary Kay
December 15, 2004 at 8:18 am
18“For tell me, sirs, if you have ever reflected upon it, by how much do those who have gained by war fall short of the number of those who have perished in it? No doubt you will reply that there can be no comparison, that the dead cannot be numbered, while the living who have been rewarded may be summed up with three figures.” Don Quixote
Sharon
December 15, 2004 at 9:03 am
19Mr. Felber, you cut right to the heart of the matter, as usual. Why you aren’t doing the news on NPR, I’ll never understand.
I’m another one with no teevee (well, technicvally, with no cable, which in my neighborhood is the same thing), and I’m getting pretty sick and tired of the fluff pieces that take up so much airtime on NPR, when there are so many other serious issues that should be investigated and discussed. Each week I get the sickening feeling more and more that NPR is just becoming another mouthpiece for the regime of George II.
Lynne
December 15, 2004 at 11:02 am
20When Ted Koppel read the names of our soldiers killed ABC stations around the country would not air Night Line. We just can’t seem to face what’s going on over there.
The Snooze hour ends each program with a picture, the home town and the age of soldiers killed in Iraq. I watch it but cannot remember the names of any of them but they all seem so young, too young to be killed in a senseless war.
Sorry I’m not being amusing. I just don’t have the irony in me today.
Michael
December 15, 2004 at 11:34 am
21Actually, Karen, you were right the first time. “Your” is the possessive case. “You’re” is the contraction of “you are.”
Proud to be contributing thoughts of substance and relavence,
m
Harold
December 15, 2004 at 12:25 pm
22Good Morning America ran a meta-story today on “Will The Scott Peterson Jurors Lives Return To Normal Now”? They dedicated a good 5 minutes or so to interviewing these folks. Unless their lives previously involved being interviewed by GMA, I would have to say the answer is “No”.
News Directors must be pissing in their pants. Scott Peterson has been their greatest work eliminator since the O.J. trial.
NPR’s “Morning Edition” periodically does profiles on soldiers who have been killed, interviewing family, friends, teachers, and fellow soldiers. I wonder what would happen if GMA did that? I could hear the heds rolling at ABC just thinking about it…
Harold
December 15, 2004 at 12:26 pm
23“heads”, sorry. I used the aorist pluperfect form of that word by mistake.
kelli
December 15, 2004 at 12:29 pm
24When did the fetus get a name? Last time I paid attention there wer only Laci and the Husband involved.
One more question:
Were they planning on having a large family? Could the deaths of the twelve children they hoped to be blessed with also be counted in an American court?
Jerry
December 15, 2004 at 2:09 pm
25Harold - not to worry. There is the Hacking trial (buried his wife in a landfill) and of course Robert Blake coming up. There will always be white women murdered under mysterious and/or bizarre circumstances to occupy and gratify news directors and fuel endless hours of pointless speculation in a world where, lets face it, there really isn’t much else going on.
Kelli - the fetus has had a name since early on, at least since the decision to charge Peterson it’s murder. The newsies, not wanting to use the word “fetus,” but still retaining enough integrity not to call it “Laci’s unborn toddler,” then adopted the name it was believed Scott and Laci intended to name it.
And, no, the theocracy isn’t yet fully establish, and there aren’t yet any laws such as you suggest, nor against birth contol or “masturbation in avoidance of conception.”
Sharon
December 15, 2004 at 2:14 pm
26Masturbation will be a felony only for men, though, right?
{worried}
Allison in Santa Cruz
December 15, 2004 at 3:11 pm
27One stupid little thing (among MANY) others about the “news” coverage of Scott Peterson’s conviction is that I’ve not once heard any newsreader referring to Conner Peterson as “their” son. They always say something like “Laci Peterson and her unborn child,” as though forgetting that the child had a father, who, incidentally, happened to be the man who killed them both. I’ve been skipping over the coverage in the SF Chronicle, so I don’t know what they’re doing with the names.
I haven’t watched TV news for years now. There’s just no point. And sometimes even NPR sounds a little too dumbed-down for my taste, especially Day to Day. I was excited about a new NPR studio out here in California, but really, they call that a news show? I suppose it qualifies, if you count LA/Hollywood trends as news. NPR doesn’t seem to have realized that there’s more to the west coast than Los Angeles.
Sharon — Don’t worry, I’m sure that only male masturbation will be a felony. Something about spilling seed on the ground, I think.
Dee
December 15, 2004 at 3:34 pm
28“Felony Onanism” — just rolls off the tongue, n’est-ce-pas?
I watch NewsHour. I have no cable. I usually fall asleep to BBC World News. I was blissfully unaware of either this verdict or the sentence for days.
And even though it pains me to say this, NPR has not been very helpful lately. Morning Edition has become way too cloying; I think they’ve come up with all these Special Correspondent segments because they keep kicking people upstairs and have to find something for them to do.
Frederick
December 15, 2004 at 8:58 pm
30Zing! Great post.
Jerry
December 15, 2004 at 9:42 pm
31Actually, Onan got smoted for failing to get his deceased brother’s widow prenant, so there is a a lot of slack for midsemeanor masturbation. Reasonably, only male masturbation could become a crime under the common misinterpretation of the story of Onan, but equality would require applying the law to both men and women. Besides, theoneocons can’t stand the thought of women enjoying sex under the best circumstances.
theconversationalist
December 15, 2004 at 9:53 pm
32what a strange irony it would be if Connor was the name the father had liked but not the murdered mother? Mayhap that’s why he killed her?
Sorry to sound flippant, but I’ve no news whatsoever of this story as we in Australia are more worried about what our swimmers, cricketers, and football players are doing. Oh, and not to mention how much money crooked CEO’s receive on being sacked for negligence in asbestos related deaths. Oh yeah and how pathetic our main opposition party is. And one mustn’t forget the war, and coverage of all those poor Iraqi servicemen getting killed by their own people. And I truly do feel for those of you who have lost people in that war. Our red-neck, wealth loving, Dubya loving prime minister has had the good fortune not to have any Australians lost over there yet.
Feel free to visit my blog as listed or also at this address:http://crapparties.blogspot.com/
keep up the great work Adam et al. We here in Australia thought you crazy ‘yanks’ were all red-neck illiterates, but alas there may be hope for you all yet.
:-)
penny ashford
December 15, 2004 at 10:07 pm
33Dear Adam - Another reader from Australia here. I was one of the people who forwarded your concession speech all over the place (without credit and I am very sorry about that, but have been diligent with all other forwards from your site). Just wanted to say that it is great to be able to check in every day to FA. Australia is not in much better shape. Many thanks.
Jay
December 15, 2004 at 10:33 pm
34Wesley Joel Canning, USMC, killed in Fallujah November 12, 2004.
Nephew of a very close friend.
Katie
December 15, 2004 at 11:53 pm
35www.cnn.com/SPECIALS/2003/iraq/forces/casualties/
sorry. I still don’t know how to make it a nifty link. But you can cut and paste. The end result is the same.
And the 1 you never hear of: SPC Matt Maupin. 20yrs old (or would he be 21 now?) The only POW. From a small town in Ohio. Been missing almost a year. Is he still alive? I doubt it. If he is, I pray for the hell he has seen, and the scars he will live with forever.
Oh, and don’t forget the wounded. roughly 10,000 now. I played a concert at the MN Veteran’s hospital last week. There were so many YOUNG people there. At first I thought they were visiting relatives, and then I realized that these KIDS were wounded vets. Arms, legs, burns…
Yeah, “if it bleeds, it leads… unless it wears a US Service uniform”
God bless our Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen, and Marines. Men and Women. Come home soon.
pjk
December 16, 2004 at 5:18 am
36Adam, I agree with the motivation for the post. There’s a lot of intentional diversion being employed by the SCLM and their RNC-contributing masters.
I also agree with everyone who has the opinion that killing your wife and unborn child is a bad thing.
However, I sure as hell wouldn’t like to be the poor son of a bitch that the media focuses on and plays a major part in convicting with wholly circumstantial evidence.
If he actually did it, fine. But they had to re-shuffle the jury a few times in order to come up with the desired result.
Now the residents of California can be amused by his countless appeals at their own expense, regardless of whether they “found” him guilty or not. Enjoy the continuing saga, boys and girls!
Ananna
December 16, 2004 at 5:36 am
37And still everyone forgets the 20,000 to 100,000 or more Iraqi people who have been killed in the war, the uncounted (and undoubtedly insanely high number of) wounded, displaced, the refugees.
Their names appear nowhere. We bury them in mass graves, under the rubble of half the mosques of Faloojah, once known as the “City of Mosques”. Now it is a city of horrors where feral dogs feed on corpses in the streets.
I have love for the “coalition” soldiers as people, but not as the followers of orders that brought this about. I also have love for the Iraqi people who bear a far harsher burden than Americans will ever begin to contemplate.
We are no angels, none of us. Yet, it is a worthy goal to try to love each other, even those who don’t love us back. Especially those who don’t love us back. They may have a damned good reason.
Love,
Hanna
Lindsay
December 16, 2004 at 12:39 pm
38“! A guy kills his pregnant wife, there’s a ton of evidence against him, his alibis aren’t credible, and the jury finds him guilty. Who woulda seen that coming?”
You might be surprised.
But I do agree with the thrust of your gist, definitely. I gave up watching the TV news after their disgraceful coverage of the 2000 election. I don’t miss it. Frankly, fark.com is a much better news source than any of the major networks, and that’s pretty damn sad.
Sharon
December 16, 2004 at 4:22 pm
39War is hell, for all concerned. (Except, of course, for the chickenhawks back in D.C.) Many of those soldiers and civilians who survive with limbs intact will suffer mental injuries far worse. I commend for your reading a review in the 12/16 issue of NY Review of Books at .
I started to read reviewer Chris Hedges’s book, “War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning”, a few months ago, but I couldn’t bear it, and put it down for another time.
Sharon
December 16, 2004 at 4:22 pm
40Huh? why didn’t the link appear? Try again:
http://www.nybooks.com/articles/17630.
Murray
December 16, 2004 at 7:44 pm
41Katie-
Even Clarinet players are paying hell for this war, hang in there.
Dee-
I too fall asleep listening to the BBC, even when I’m driving. I hate to say it, but they put more effort into being boring than any one possibly should.
tim gueguen
December 17, 2004 at 12:13 am
42Come on, everyone knows Scott Peterson is just the victim of “a lynch-mob inspired by witches out to avert the attention on the growing satanist population and the rituals that DO happen.” http://www.renewamerica.us/columns/shroder/041213
(If I tried to make up something like that people would call me a bad writer.)
kelli
December 17, 2004 at 1:39 pm
43“Every sperm is sacred…”
Murray
December 17, 2004 at 7:17 pm
44Tim gueguen,
An interesting side note.
One of the largest collection of “earth religions” is located only 7 miles from here. The 4 Quarters Inter Faith Center is for anyone who wants to practice what ever they can come up with. Druid, Wicca, New age, Catholic, no matter.
http://www.4qf.org/_Samhain/index.htm
They seem like pretty nice folks and as yet have not turned me into a frog or put a hex on my bike.