WASHINGTON, May 25 (New York Times) — An Army summary of deaths and mistreatment involving prisoners in American custody in Iraq and Afghanistan shows a widespread pattern of abuse involving more military units than previously known.
The cases from Iraq date back to April 15, 2003, a few days after Saddam Hussein’s statue was toppled in a Baghdad square, and they extend up to last month, when a prisoner detained by Navy commandos died in a suspected case of homicide blamed on “blunt force trauma to the torso and positional asphyxia.”
Among previously unknown incidents are the abuse of detainees by Army interrogators from a National Guard unit attached to the Third Infantry Division, who are described in a document obtained by The New York Times as having “forced into asphyxiation numerous detainees in an attempt to obtain information” during a 10-week period last spring.
The document, dated May 5, is a synopsis prepared by the Criminal Investigation Command at the request of Army officials grappling with intense scrutiny prompted by the circulation the preceding week of photographs of prisoner abuse at Abu Ghraib. It lists the status of investigations into three dozen cases, including the continuing investigation into the notorious abuses at Abu Ghraib.
_________________________________
White House spokesman Scott McClellan was quick to condemn the Army’s characterization of the abuses as “widespread” or representing a “pattern.”
“As far as our investigation has determined, each of the 36 cases is representative of isolated incidents perpetrated by a few individuals,” McClellan said. “It’s pretty clear that things happened, but we’re confident that any authorization for any alleged abuses happened at levels no higher than direct evidence documents. These guys were acting on their own, and they don’t reflect the values of anybody who hasn’t been caught.”
McClellan described any similarities between the 36 isolated cases as “a really amazing coincidence” or the actions of “a few sick individuals who traveled a lot.”
McClellan also pointed out that the incidents themselves were isolated in terms of what parts of the prisoners were abused. “Take the beatings,” he said. “Deplorable, yes, but often they were isolated, for example, to just the head and some parts of the torso. Sometimes as much as 76% of a prisoner’s body was treated completely humanely and in accordance with the Geneva Convention. But you guys never report that.“





13 comments
littlebit
May 26, 2004 at 4:09 pm
1I’m outraged by your outra….
Dang. You keep bringing up the truth about stuff.
Mojo
May 26, 2004 at 5:08 pm
2I finally managed to access the Army’s interrogation manual. Here’s an extract from the procedures for questioning prisoners.
“You have the right (right cross) to remain silent (dunk head under water; wait two minutes). Anything you say (pull head out of water to give suspect an opportunity to confess) can (your choice of objects inserted) and will be used against you in a court of law (or it would if we ever intended to let you have a trial). You have the right (put the electrodes “right” here) to an attorney (our lawyer, who will state that these actions are in full compliance with the Geneva Convention) and for an attorney (and biting dogs) to be present during questioning (the lawyer can hold the leash around your neck). If you can not afford an attorney (since you’ve been unable to work for the three months we’ve held you so far), one will be appointed (female guard “point” to nude prisoner and laugh) for you. Do you understand these rights as I’ve read them to you? (If prisoner answers affirmatively, he understands English so he must be a terrorist.)”
Anonymous
May 26, 2004 at 6:50 pm
3It seems to be working. Everyone is so tied up in this Iraq thing that I can do whatever I want elsewhere.
It’s time to increase the funding for my pet missile defense shield. Thank God no-one has noticed that it offers no protection against fallout or the nuclear winter that will result in any nuclear war. It really is about as much use as an umbrella in a flood. But what the hey, I’m strong on defense ad I even convinced the Japanese, the Aussies, and the Canadians to help.
Lots more money for our Defense contractors and lots more for my campaign fund.
Ain’t life grand.
Dubya
May 26, 2004 at 6:58 pm
4Must remember to practice my speeches more.
I almost let slip our private name for those ‘alleged’ abuses in Iraq.
Abu GrabaAss would have cost me a few votes with those bleeding hearts.
Note–
1. Get Tom R. to write more of those
warrants.
2. Make sure Martha gets off, I need the money for ads.
3. Learn English
4. Forget 3. I forgot I screwed up the Educational system.
5. Get someone to write the new constitution, that Orwell guy had the right idea.
littlebit
May 26, 2004 at 7:23 pm
5Ha, Dubya, I love #3.
Snerk.
Bob
May 26, 2004 at 8:00 pm
6Here’s hoping that this fall, millions of people who sat on their butts during the last election will, in isolated incidents, go to their polling places and vote out Scott McClellan’s boss, thus propelling Mr. McClellan into some cushy corporate sinecure where he can tell lies to stockholders. I mean, if we’re really, really lucky.
Jerry
May 27, 2004 at 4:11 am
7I know very little about this site (input, please) but if it is not wildly weird, this is scary and seems to fit a lot of my observations.
http://www.tbrnews.org/Archives/a887.htm
Jerry
May 27, 2004 at 4:20 am
8Bob - and hoping that Greens will adopt the wise advice to “vote your heart in the primary, and your head in the general elections.”
Latest from here in Cal is that Kerry is ahead even in a three-way race!
Landis
May 27, 2004 at 6:12 pm
9>Latest from here in Cal is that Kerry is ahead even in a three-way race!
That’s not saying a whole lot considering it’s California. I’ll start to be a little less tense if I see numbers like that coming out of Texas.
Until then I think I’ll be holding my breath until November.
Murray
May 27, 2004 at 9:14 pm
10So McClellan sees the cases as “a really amazing coincidence”, I guess that I would see it as an unbelievable coincidence.
But hey, no other nation on earth is great enough to say “we’re sorry” like we do, and besides we’re going to tear down the old prison and put up a new one. “Hey Halliburton, you got an opening in your schedule?”
Michael
May 27, 2004 at 11:23 pm
11Hey Adam - it’s Michael D from the “old neighborhood.” Damn that sounds so Sopranos…
Anyway, I heard you on Air America, found your site, and I’ve been cracking up…
Great work!
Deborah
May 28, 2004 at 12:43 am
12Adam was on Air America! Dang, I missed it. Which show - maybe I can catch it on the weekend reruns.
Murray
May 28, 2004 at 8:31 am
13You holding out on us Adam?